12 Favorite Ice Cream and Frozen Yogurt Spots in and Around Boston

sweet summer treats - ice cream and kids in boston

We thought we’d take advantage of some free time this summer and make our own ice cream. After all, how tough could it be? But by the time we had Googled a recipe (found plenty that did not require a machine) and made a list of ingredients we needed, the enthusiasm had waned, and we decided it would probably be best if we left the ice cream making to our favorite ice cream shop and enjoy the fruits of their labor!

From good quality ice cream chains founded right here in New England to one-of-a-kind specialty shops, there are plenty of places for Boston families to satisfy that need for something cold and sweet to beat the heat. Read on to find some of our favorite ice cream and frozen yogurt experiences.

ICE CREAM

Bedford Farms
18 North Road, Bedford and 68 Thoreau Street, Concord
Bedford Farms has been making ice cream since the late 1800s, and now serves a wide variety of premium ice cream flavors, gourmet frozen yogurt selections, and soft serve ice cream in Bedford (picnic tables available) and Concord (indoor seating available).


Christina’s Ice Cream
1255 Cambridge St, Cambridge
Daily, 11:30am-10:30pm

Unusual and inventive flavors - typically over 50! - make each visit to Christina’s an adventure.


The Chilly Cow
451 Massachusetts Avenue, Arlington
One of only a handful of shops that makes frozen custard (a midwestern-style ice cream). It also serves ice cream made by Shain's of Maine Ice Cream, frozen yogurt, sherbet and sorbet.


Crescent Ridge Dairy Bar
355 Bay Road, Sharon
You can enjoy 44 flavors of delicious, super premium ice cream that starts with the 40-year-old Parrish family recipe and is carefully churned and hand packed. (We know they start with great milk - delivered to our door for years!) Visit the cows at the Sharon location; play mini golf in Holbrook.


J.P. Licks
Locations in: Jamaica Plain, Boston, Cambridge, Brookline, Newton, West Roxbury, Dedham, and Wellesley
J.P. Licks features special Ice cream flavors use fresh, seasonal ingredients (try one of the peach-based flavors this month!), hard frozen yogurt, and regular flavors throughout the year. They also roast their own coffee, and have hand-made ice cream cakes that can be picked up in the stores or customized (with 48 hours notice). The first shop opened in 1981 in Jamaica Plain (“J.P.”).


Kimball Farm
Three locations in MA: 400 Littleton Road/Rte. 110, Westford; 1543 Lunenberg Road (Rt. 70), Lancaster; 343 Bedford Rd. (Rt. 225), Carlisle
Kimball’s is famous for its huge portions and delicious homemade flavors (be prepared to wait in line!). The Westford location is a “destination” spot - you can play mini golf, ride the bumper boats, or try the nine-hole pitch-n-putt and a driving range while you’re there.


Rancatore's
Three locations: 36 Leonard Street, Belmont; 1752 Massachusetts Ave, Lexington; 333 Walnut Street, Newtonville 
Open daily 10am-11pm

Rancatore’s makes its ice cream in a small batch freezer at a factory behind its Lexington store. Try multiple flavors (you can have two flavors in the small, three in the medium, and up to four in the large) to find your favorite!


Toscanini’s
899 Main Street, Cambridge
Daily 8am-11pm

A Cambridge favorite since 1981, Toscanini’s serves up some of the most unique and best-tasting flavors around often taking inspiration from what’s in season.


White Farms Ice Cream
326 High Street, Ipswich. (978) 356-2633
Open daily (Mar-Oct) 11:30am-10pm

A long-time favorite of beach-goers and others, White Farms has been making its own ice cream since the early 1950s. and serves up huge portions of old time favorites like chocolate chip and strawberry and more creative flavors like Caramel Cow and Outrageous, plus soft serve flavors, ice cream sundaes, and frappes. Picnic tables are available (no indoor facilities).


FROZEN YOGURT

It’s all about the toppings at frozen yogurt shops these days. The following offer good-tasting yogurt and an enticing array of toppings:

Berryline
Locations: Porter Square, Harvard Square, and Fenway.
Berryline is a locally owned business serving a rich and creamy frozen yogurt in creative and indulgent flavors, plus tons of toppings.  Check the individual locations for store hours.


Mixx
66 Brighton Avenue, Boston
Mon-Wed: 1pm-11pm; Thu-Sun 12n-11pm

Mixx is a locally owned specialty frozen yogurt shop that offers 10 yogurt flavors and as many as 50 toppings each week.


Pinkberry
We’ve made plenty of visits to Pinkberry in Harvard Square for their frozen yogurt and great selection of toppings. And we like the fact that flavors are either non-fat or low-fat. Additional locations are in Boston, Braintree, Hingham, North Beverly, and Wellesley.


Of course, we also love Ben & Jerry’s and Emack & Bolio’s (locations throughout the area) and can always count on them for a tasty ice cream outing.

Originally published July 2012 by Audrey T. Updated July 2015 by Tara D.