MommyPoppins.com
MAKE YOUR DAY
Get Listed Log In Sign Up My Profile Sign out Contact
New York City
  • Anywhere
  • New York City
  • Dallas Fort Worth
  • Atlanta
  • Boston
  • Chicago
  • Houston
  • Miami South Florida
  • Philadelphia
  • Washington DC
  • Orlando
  • Los Angeles
  • San Francisco Bay Area
  • Connecticut
  • Long Island
  • New Jersey
  • Westchester
Get Listed Log In Sign Up My Profile Sign out Contact

HOME - New York City

Activity Calendar

Providers

Calendar  
  • Events

  • Deals

  • This Week's Picks

  • Activity Providers

  • Submit an Activity

NYC Guide  
  • News & Openings

  • NYC Baby Guide

  • NYC for Preschoolers

  • Tweens & Teens

  • Neighborhood Guides

  • Parks & Playgrounds

  • Free Activities

  • Visitors' Guide to NYC

  • Restaurants

  • NYC Moving Guide

Things To Do  
  • Crafts for Kids

  • Recipes

  • Science for Kids

  • Games & Activities

  • Outdoors

  • Online & Virtual

Camps & Classes  
  • Camps Guide

  • Classes Guide

  • Preschools & Schools Guide

  • Directory

Parties & Holidays  
  • Gift Guide

  • Birthday Parties

  • Party Providers

  • Holidays

  • Spring Guide

  • Summer Guide

  • Fall Guide

  • Winter Guide

Family Travel  
  • Day Trips

  • Family Vacations

  • Theme & Water Parks

  • Resorts & Hotels

  • Adirondacks

  • Hamptons & North Fork

  • Poconos Guide

  • Jersey Shore Guide

Contact

Sign up for our free newsletters.
Create your very own mixed-media paintings inspired by Wave Hill’s Aquatic Garden at Monet's Magnificent Pond. Photo by Joshua Bright
Moths, Monet, and More Fun Things To Do this Weekend in NYC with Kids
The splash pad in Domino Park puts a smile on faces young and old. Photo by Jody Mercier
Ultimate 2025 Guide to NYC Splash Pads and Water Playgrounds
Noshing on a funnel cake on the Coney Island boardwalk is a sweet ending to an epic day of summer fun.
Our Epic 2025 Summer Bucket List of Things To Do in NYC with Kids
GUIDE
NYC Kids Summer Guide: 728 Best Festivals, Deals, Activities & Free Things to Do
Head to the Bronx's Haffen Pool, one of our favorite free pools in NYC, to enjoy a day of swimming and splashing.
Best Free Swimming Pools in NYC for Families During Summer 2025
Celebrate all things French when Bastille Day takes over Madison Avenue with a blocks-long street fest. Photo by Michael George
20 Best Things To Do in NYC July 2025 with Kids: Macy's 4th of July Fireworks and More
Find the best free and cheap activities in your city this summer with Mommy Poppins.
Summer of Savings 2025: Save Money on Kids Activities and Travel This Summer with Mommy Poppins
Tom's Restaurant is situated on a fairly sleepy corner in Morningside Heights despite its high-profile turn in Seinfeld. Photo by Jody Mercier
Lights, Camera, New York! Where to Find Iconic NYC Movie Sites with
Slip and slide your way to smiles during Asphalt Green's Sprinkler Day. Photo courtesy of Asphalt Green
Free Activities in July: 81 Best Things To Do with Kids in NYC
Explore the parks and beaches on Staten Island, one of our 100 favorite free things to do this summer in NYC. Photo by Sara M.
NYC Summer Fun: 100 Amazing FREE Activities for Kids in 2025
Enjoy the popular Movies With a View series at Brooklyn Bridge Park in July and August. Photo by Etienne Frossard
Free Outdoor Movies in NYC Summer 2025 for Kids
Start the summer with free musical entertainment at Live at the Archway in Dumbo. Photo by Noemie Trusty.
Free 2025 NYC Summer Concerts and Outdoor Music Festivals for Families
Diving into the sprinkle pool at the Museum of Ice Cream is a great way to cure rainy day blues. Photo by  Jody Mercier
47 Fun Indoor Activities in NYC for a Rainy Day
Vinland Playground got a fresh upgrade in Bay Ridge. Photo by NYC Parks/Daniel Avila
Jaw-Dropping New Playgrounds in NYC to Explore with Kids Now
Summer camps help kids develop social skills and have fun
GUIDE
NYC Summer Camp Guide
The Peninsula New York rolls out the red carpet for kids—and their grown ups!
Family-Friendly Hotels in New York City with Perks for Kids
Climb on platforms dangling from ropes at Hester Street Playground. Photo by Jody Mercier
NYC's Best Playgrounds: 21 Parks Worthy of a Subway Schlep
There's always a cool new piece of public art to see and interact with in NYC. Photo by Jody Mercier
100 Free Things To Do in NYC with Kids
The 2025-2026 public school year for NYC kids starts on Thursday, September 4.
Here's the NYC Public School Calendar for 2025-2026
Brooklyn's Flying Apple offers action-packed fun for kids of all ages.
24 Best Kids' Indoor Playgrounds and Play Spaces in NYC
Discover the NYC-themed play space hidden inside the Toys
27 Free Things To Do Indoors in NYC: Free Places To Play Indoors on Cold and Rainy Days
Teens have the opportunity to explore arts careers and institutions with Whitney Museum Youth Insights Program. Photo by Diana Kim
Teens Can Apply Now for Summer Internships in NYC
The Ausable Chasm has been described as the Grand Canyon of the Adirondacks and it's one of our top 100 things to do in New York State with kids. Photo by Anna Fader
Ultimate New York Bucket List: 100 Things To Do with Kids in NY State
Hell's Kitchen is a cool coming-of-age piece loosely based on Alicia Keys' life story. Photo by Marc J. Franklin
Best New Broadway Shows This Season Plus Can't-Miss Classics for Families
Photo courtesy of PLAY Greenpoint.
GUIDE
Guide to Indoor Playgrounds and Play Spaces in NYC
Free activities for Kids in NYC include the Children's Museum of the Arts, which has pay-what-you-wish Thursdays from 4-6pm. Photo courtesy of the museum
GUIDE
Free Things To Do in NYC with Kids Guide
Visit the 180 Pool at the Crystal Springs Resort. Photo courtesy of the resort
14 Family-Friendly Weekend Getaways near NYC
Explore modern humanity through all-new world-wandering exhibitions at Mmuseumm.
Weird, Wacky, and Wonderful Under-the-Radar Museums in NYC that Kids Love
Kids' classes like art lessons can help your NYC child grow and develop
GUIDE
Guide to NYC Classes for Kids
For an only-in-NYC experience, head to the Top of the Rock to enjoy the view. Photo by Jody Mercier
Best Attractions and Things To Do near NYC that are Kid-Friendly
Tea Around Town combines a sumptuous meal with a unique view NYC landmarks! Photo by Jody Mercier
25 Best NYC Tours for Families: From Boat Rides to Free Walking Tours and More
The American Museum of Natural History's blue whale is an NYC icon, and the entire museum is one of the best children's museums in NYC. Photo by R. Mickens/courtesy of AMNH
Best Museums for Kids in NYC: Children's Museums and Family-Friendly Museums in NYC
GUIDE
Guide to Kids' Birthday Parties in NYC
Registration is now open for the reasonably priced summer camps at YMCA locations in NYC.
Free and Cheap Summer Camps in NYC for Kids
The Maritime Aquarium at Norwalk has 75 animal exhibits and is home to more than 7,000 animals. Photo courtesy of the aquarium
Best Aquariums to Visit from the NYC Metro Area with Kids
Get a Broadway-caliber serenade during a birthday dinner at Ellen's Stardust Diner.
Best Fun Restaurants for Kids' Birthdays in NYC
See the skyline from a whole new vantage point on the Roosevelt Island Tram. Photo courtesy of NYCGo
Ultimate New York City Bucket List: 100 Things To Do in NYC with Kids Before They Grow Up
Get a birds eye view of the skyline from the Edge observation deck at Hudson Yards. Plan a visit near sundown to watch the city lights come to life. Photo by Jody Mercier
3 Days in NYC with Kids: Ultimate Itinerary by a Local Mom
Feed a crowd with extra large, classic, New York-style pizza slices without breaking the bank. Photo by Jody Mercier
NYC on a Budget: Cheap Things To Do and Money Saving Tips for Families
These boredom-busting activities turn a stuck-at-home day into a lasting memory.
75 Indoor Activities for Kids on a Rainy Day
The Met offers pay-what-you wish admission at all times to New Yorkers and kids always attend for free. Photo by Jody Mercier
Free Museums and Free Museum Days in NYC for Kids
Kids can while away hours of a day with a set of watercolors and a stack of new paper for painting. Photo by Sara Marentette
Crafts for Kids: 100 Awesome Art Projects
No visit to NYC is complete without an up-close encounter with the Statue of Liberty. Photo by Jess Laird
40 Best NYC Attractions to Do with Kids Right Now
Teach 'em to tie during downtime.
65 Life Skills to Teach Kids at Every Age
GUIDE
NYC Kids Summer Guide: 728 Best Festivals, Deals, Activities & Free Things to Do
Take a hike with your little one on a family day trip from NYC.
GUIDE
Family Day Trips and Weekend Getaways for NYC Kids
Creating a baking soda volcano is a classic science experiment for kids. Photo by Sara Marentette Nighswander
67 Easy Science Experiments for Kids To Do at Home
Hester Street Playground. Photo by Jody Mercier
GUIDE
Playgrounds & Parks NYC Guide
Suncatcher_Liz Baill @creativishmom
GUIDE
Crafts for Kids Guide: Thousands of Craft Ideas
FIND AND BOOK ACTIVITIES
calendar icon
This Week In
New York City
Wild at Night at Wave Hill
Wave Hill - 8:00 AM Pick
Le Carrousel Extravaganza in Bryant Park
Bryant Park Carousel - 10:00 AM Pick
Opening Week: World of Darkness at the Bronx Zoo
Bronx Zoo - 10:00 AM Pick
CityParks PuppetMobile Presents Pippi Longstocking in Crocheron Park
Crocheron Park - 11:00 AM Pick
Picnic Performances in Bryant Park
Bryant Park - 7:00 PM Pick
Featured
Storytelling at the Hans Christian Andersen Statue in Central Park
Central Park Hans Christian Andersen Statue - 11:00 AM
Iggy Peck, Architect at the Skyscraper Museum
The Skyscraper Museum - 10:30 AM Pick
Opening Week: World of Darkness at the Bronx Zoo
Bronx Zoo - 10:00 AM Pick
Farmhouse Family Day: Creative Critters
Wyckoff House Museum - 11:00 AM Pick
Rock and Roll Playhouse Concert at Grand Central Terminal
Grand Central Terminal - 11:00 AM Pick
Featured
Breed Spotlight: Maltese at The Museum of the Dog
Museum of the Dog - 12:00 PM
Queens Day in Flushing Meadows Corona Park
Flushing Meadows Corona Park - 9:00 AM Pick
Opening Week: World of Darkness at the Bronx Zoo
Bronx Zoo - 10:00 AM Pick
Bubble Bonanza at Old Stone House
Old Stone House - 10:00 AM Pick
Drums of Freedom at Lefferts Historic House - CANCELED
Lefferts Homestead - 2:00 PM Pick
Le Carrousel Extravaganza in Bryant Park
Bryant Park Carousel - 10:00 AM Pick
Broadway by the Boardwalk in Clinton Cove
Clinton Cove Pier 96 - 6:30 PM Pick
Bond with Brooklyn Outdoor Movies in Pacific Park
Pacific Park - various times Pick
Mini Quest : Family-Friendly Scavenger Hunt
Battery Park City, Tribeca or South Street Seaport - 8:00 AM
Sloomoo Institute
Sloomoo Institute - 10:00 AM
Featured
Emanu-El Downtown Unplugged at Pier 57
Pier 57 Rooftop Park - 10:00 AM
Stargazing on The High Line
The High Line - 7:30 PM Pick
Naumburg Orchestral Concerts
Central Park - Naumburg Bandshell - 7:30 PM Pick
Seaport Cinema at Pier 17
South Street Seaport Pier 17 - 7:30 PM Pick
Memnon in Marcus Garvey Park
Marcus Garvey Park Amphitheater - 8:30 PM Pick
Le Carrousel Extravaganza in Bryant Park
Bryant Park Carousel - 10:00 AM Pick
Tavern Tales at Fraunces Tavern
Fraunces Tavern Museum - 1:00 PM Pick
Hippo Playground Summer Concert Series
Hippo Playground - 3:30 PM Pick
Boogie Woogie Wednesdays: Eastern European Music and Dancing at SI Children's Museum
Staten Island Childrens Museum - 3:30 PM Pick
Summer Concerts at the Hudson Yards
Hudson Yards Public Square and Gardens - 5:00 PM Pick
Children’s Performance Series in Riverside Park
Riverside Park - Pier I - 10:00 AM Pick
Creative Drama Kids' Theater Class at Lincoln Center
Lincoln Center - Library for the Performing Arts - 11:00 AM Pick
Broadway in Bryant Park
Bryant Park - 12:30 PM Pick
Big City Fishing at Pier 26
Pier 26 in Hudson River Park - 3:00 PM Pick
Live at the Archway in Dumbo
Archway under the Manhattan Bridge - 6:00 PM Pick
SEE ALL ACTIVITIES
SUBMIT AN ACTIVITY +
Storytelling at the Hans Christian Andersen Statue in Central Park
Central Park Hans Christian Andersen Statue
Breed Spotlight: Maltese at The Museum of the Dog
Museum of the Dog
Emanu-El Downtown Unplugged at Pier 57
Pier 57 Rooftop Park
Sign up for our free newsletters.
FOLLOW US FOR ACTIVITY PICKS, DEALS, AND GIVEAWAYS
FaceBook Instagram Twitter Pinterest YouTube
Activity Guides
  • Beaches & Lakes
  • Best Of Lists
  • Birthday Parties
  • Boats
  • Boredom Busters
  • Camps
  • Childcare
  • Christmas/Hanukkah
  • City Guides
  • City Hacks
  • Classes & Enrichment
  • Community
  • Crafts & Recipes
  • Earth Kids
  • Easter
  • Fairs & Festivals
  • Fall Activities
  • Family Travel
  • Farms & U-Pick
  • Free Activities
  • GoList
  • Halloween
  • Holidays
  • Hotels & Resorts
  • Indoor Activities
  • Museums
  • News & Openings
  • Outdoors
  • Parent Talk
  • Parks & Playgrounds
  • Play Gyms & Sports Centers
  • Pools & Spray Parks
  • Preschools & Schools
  • Restaurants
  • Shows
  • Skiing & Winter Sports
  • Special Needs
  • Special Occasions
  • Sports
  • Spring Activities
  • STEM
  • Stores & Services
  • Summer Activities
  • Theme & Water Parks
  • Trains, Dinos & Heroes
  • TV, Film & Movies
  • Virtual
  • Visitors Guide
  • Weekend Events
  • Weekend Trips
  • Winter Activities
  • Zoos & Gardens
Twitter Facebook LinkedIn Pin It WhatsApp

Kid Detectives Can Try to Solve the Interactive Pinkertonian Mystery at the New-York Historical Society

2/11/15 - By Raven Snook

My daughter is the kind of kid who just can't let a mystery go. If someone eats the last cookie or finally throws out her stale Halloween candy, she'll seek out clues until she finds the culprit. (Mysteries in our house always seem to revolve around food for some reason.) So when I heard that the New-York Historical Society was hosting an interactive, historical whodunnit for kids, I knew it was right up my junior detective's dark, mysterious alley, so we jumped at the chance to attend the final dress rehearsal.

Created by the innovative Live in Theater troupe, which is known for mounting immersive experiences, The Pinkertonian Mystery takes you throughout the museum as you try to catch cunning jewel thief El Diablo. Initially I figured I would just hang back and let the children enjoy themselves, but as we ran around the galleries interviewing suspects and deciphering clues, I became just as invested in the outcome as my kid.

OUR LATEST VIDEOS

The Pinkertonian Mystery is a two-hour experience inspired by the real-life Pinkerton Detective Agency, which was founded in the mid-19th-century and still exists today. This particular case is set in 1875 and features historical figures like agency founder Allan Pinkerton and the U.S.'s first female detective, Kate Warne. The show starts with fun detective games, like cracking codes and trying to stealthily steal a handkerchief out of a detective's back pocket. Pay attention! Some of these activities will come in handy later.

Soon Mr. Pinkerton himself appears and, after a little historical chitchat including a bit about the Orphan Trains, he says he needs our help tracking down the elusive El Diablo... and suddenly the criminal strikes again, stealing rubies right from under our noses!

Families are organized into teams, given maps and a list of questions to ask suspects, and go off. At each location, you interact with one of the seven cast members, who supply clues as well as red herrings. I found that after the first stop we rarely stuck to the questions. The kids just chatted the actors up. Thankfully they were all great at improving (no matter what the kids came up with they all had great responses), and they also made sure we completed our required tasks. Often we figured out what we needed to do pretty quickly though sometimes we needed extra help.

I don't want to say too much more since it is a mystery after all. The experience is recommended for ages 8 and up, and I agree. My nine-year-old and her 11-year-old friend had an awesome time, but they needed a bit of adult guidance to stay on track. Even with six adults and two kids in our group all working together, we didn't quite solve the case... but we were very close! You have to put a lot of disparate details together to make sense of what's happening.

My only quibbles: Although historical tidbits are interwoven throughout, unless you're schooled in history, you may not be able to tell fact from fiction (I had no idea Kate Warne was a real person until I looked her up). Also, even though you run around the whole New-York Historical Society, the mystery doesn't really have much to do with the exhibits on display. But no matter. We had a blast, and it's a novel and engaging way to explore this worthy museum.

The Pinkertonian Mystery takes place on Sundays, February 15, March 8, April 12 and 26, May 17, June 21, July 12 and 26 at the New-York Historical Society, 170 Central Park West at 77th Street. Tickets are $35.

Places featured in this article:

Map All Locations
Close Map X
  List All Location Details

New-York Historical Society
170 Central Park West, New York, NY 10024
Shows Museums Kids Tweens & teens Uptown Upper West Side New York City

Featured Local Savings

Sign up for our free
newsletters.
New York City
Dallas Fort Worth
Atlanta
Boston
Chicago
Houston
Miami South Florida
Philadelphia
Washington DC
Orlando
Los Angeles
San Francisco Bay Area
Connecticut
Long Island
New Jersey
Westchester
MommyPoppins.com
Mommy Poppins is a family activity website that helps people find things to do with kids.
QUICK LINKS
Activities
Providers
Family Travel
CONTACT
Newsletter Subscribe
Contact
About
SITEMAP
Submit an Activity
List Your Business
Advertise with Us
© 2025 MommyPoppins. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Terms of Use.
5.342
X
Click Here to Sign Up!
Register/Login if you don't want to see this popup.