Where to Donate Toys and Baby Gear on Long Island

The Interfaith Nutrition Network accepts donations of unopened baby items and toys.
The Interfaith Nutrition Network accepts donations of unopened baby items and toys.

If your kids are anything like most, their holiday wish lists were filled with requests for new toys. But now that your house is overflowing with new treasures, what do you do with all of the old ones or those that your child never even opened? Or all of the baby equipment that was gently—or never—used? Consider supporting one of these local charities accepting donations.

We've rounded up 11 local charities that could use your support. While most of these Long Island organizations accepted clean, working, undamaged, preowned toys and baby items before COVID, it's worth checking current donation requirements. Many organizations only accept new, unused items.

For safety reasons, most charities do not accept cribs or car seats. However, many accept strollers, bouncers, and even baby care items such as diapers. Before dropping by, contact these local charities to make sure they haven't reached their donation limits. One other tip: Ask your school, local library, or church if they can use your second-hand items. Often, those institutions are willing to accept used toys and books from someone they know and trust.

Looking for more ways to help your community? There are plenty of local volunteer opportunities for kids and families.

Girl poses with donated items at The INN
The INN relies on donations to provide a broad range of essential services to assist those challenged by hunger, homelessness, and profound poverty. Photo courtesy of The INN

Charities Accepting Donations in Nassau County

The INN — Hempstead

100 Madison Avenue
Unopened packages of baby wipes, diapers, and formula are gladly accepted year-round. You can find a list of current high-need items on its website. Donations are generally accepted on weekdays from 9-11am or 2-4:30pm.

Anna House at The Belmont Racetrack — Elmont​

2050 Hempstead Turnpike
Anna House accepts new toys and baby gear every Wednesday and Friday after 1pm. Strollers and car seats are accepted if they are new and in the box. Anna House provides affordable help for local families.

Long Island Council of Churches — Freeport

230 Hanse Avenue
The LICC says it is seeing an increase in children in need. Baby care items such as diapers and wipes are appreciated, as are unopened packages of formula. Packaged toys or those opened but in like-new condition are accepted Monday-Friday from 9am-3pm. The council is in particular need of food items like soup, oatmeal, cereal, and sauce. If you don't have goods to donate, LICC makes it easy to make monetary or food donations via its website.

Mother and Child Ministry — Seaford

2197 Jackson Avenue
St. Michael's & All Angels Episcopal Church's food shelf program now includes services for mothers with young children. Donations can be dropped off in Seaford on Wednesdays from 4-8pm and Sundays from 1-4pm. You can also make donations at its Wantagh location, the Church of St. Jude, from 8am-12 noon on Sundays and Mondays-Thursdays from 9:30am-12:30pm. Accepted items include baby care items, gently used toys, baby equipment, children's clothing, and personal care items mothers can use.

RELATED: The Long Island Places and People Who Saved Our Sanity in 2020

The Vietnam Vets will pickup your unwanted items or donations
Schedule a pickup and support the Vietnam Veterans of America charities. Photo courtesy of Vietnam Veterans of America

Charities Accepting Donations in Suffolk County

Vietnam Veterans of America — Central Islip

2 Wilson Boulevard
This nonprofit makes it easy to give. Schedule a pickup online, label, and leave your items on your porch or curb. Gently used toys, baby equipment, clothing, and household items are accepted. The organization also takes small furniture and electronics that are no more than five years old.

Goodwill Thrift Stores — East Northport

1900 East Jericho Turnpike
Drop off those gently used toys, bikes, clothes, and baby items, or check online for your nearest donation bin. Donated items are sold in stores and on an online auction site. The revenue funds valuable employment and job-placement services for those in need. More than 2,000 items are placed on Goodwill sales floors each day.

Savers — Multiple Locations

Visit the website for a list of locations.
Drop off donations at any Savers store. Accepted items include toys, sports equipment, books, stuffed animals, puzzles, games, housewares, and clothes. For every donation made, Big Brothers Big Sisters of Long Island gets a share of the profit. Savers also supports recycling by donating unsellable items to less affluent countries, where they can be used or sold.

RELATED: Volunteer Opportunities for Families on Long Island

Find a Big Brothers Big Sisters donation bin throughout Long Island
Big Brothers Big Sisters accepts books, small stuffed toys, and clothes. Photo courtesy of Big Brothers Big Sisters of Long Island

Charities Accepting Donations Throughout Long Island

Big Brothers Big Sisters of Long Island — Islandia, Westbury

145 Sycamore Lane, Islandia
25 Carle Road, Westbury
Find your nearest donation bin online or schedule a pickup. Either way, BBBS accepts new and gently used clothing, stuffed animals, small toys, and books.

Long Island Head Start — Multiple Locations

There are head start centers spread across Long Island. Currently, it is asking for donations of brand new baby clothes and other baby items. Head Start serves families below the poverty line, so donations of diapers, toiletries, mittens, hats, and coats are greatly appreciated.

Salvation Army Thrift Stores – Multiple Locations

Visit the website for drop-off locations or to schedule a pickup.
Salvation Army Thrift Stores accept various items, including toys, stuffed animals, books, and large baby items. Drop off your donations at one of the organization's many locations or schedule a pickup online. The Salvation Army also takes car donations. You can check with individual centers about donating small furniture items and appliances.

St. Vincent De Paul Thrift Stores — Huntington & Garden City

1705 Jericho Turnpike, Huntington
2160 Jericho Turnpike, Garden City Park
New and gently used baby clothes can be dropped off at either location Monday through Saturday, from 10am-5:30pm.

This article was originally posted in 2014 and was updated by writer Lisa Mancuso for 2021.

Places featured in this article:

Big Brothers Big Sisters of Long Island

Big Brothers Big Sisters of Long Island

Interfaith Nutritional Network

Vietnam Veterans of America

Salvation Army Thrift Stores

Salvation Army Thrift Store

Salvation Army Thrift Store

Salvation Army Thrift Store

Salvation Army Thrift Store

Salvation Army Thrift Store

Salvation Army Thrift Store

Salvation Army Thrift Store

Mother and Child Ministry

Long Island Council of Churches

Long Island Head Start

St. Aiden's Food Pantry
Kids Not-So-Scary Days at Bayville Scream Park
Bayville Adventure Park - 11:00 AM
Games in the Afternoon at The Babylon Library
Babylon Public Library - 1:00 PM
F.A.S.T. Program
Flanders Youth Center - 4:00 PM
Fall Festival at Hicks Nurseries
Hicks Nurseries - various times
Neighborhood Guides
Activity Guides