10 Over-the-Top Sweet Treat Experiences for NYC Kids

It's easy to find a place to drop in for a quick treat like an ice cream cone or a brownie in New York City—after all, there are delis, bodegas and bakeries on just about every corner. But sometimes you want to indulge in something more extravagant with your kids, maybe as a reward for a hard-earned report card, a special occasion or an impromptu celebration with a couple of friends. Of course, this being NYC, there are some seriously over-the-top treat experiences to be enjoyed. From chocolate pizza to tricked-out candy stores to old-fashioned sundaes bigger than your child's head, these 10 exceptional sweet spots are anything but ordinary.

Max Brenner Chocolate by the Bald Man – Union Square
841 Broadway between 13th and 14th Streets
​Max Brenner is a Willy Wonka-esque fantasy land where whirring machines spin melted chocolate alongside the dining tables, and tubes carrying the sweet stuff crisscross the ceiling. Everything imaginable that can be done with chocolate is done here. Equal parts cafe and candy shop, Max Brenner is famous for its over-the-top concoctions like chocolate pizza, syringes full of chocolate that you squirt right into your mouth, and treats that can be toasted on a table-side fire! We're longtime fans: Max Brenner made our list of the best hot cocoas in NYC, and Anna once threw a snall birthday party here.

Enjoying a NYC tradition: Frozen Hot Chocolate at Serendipity 3

Serendipity 3 – Upper East Side
225 East 60th Stree​t between Second and Third Avenues
Serendipity's Frozen Hot Chocolate is quintessential NYC. A trip here is practically a coming-of-age experience for kids in the city. And families have been celebrating life's special moments, big and small, with this delicious frozen treat since the 1950s. Also if you want to talk indulgent, Serendipity offers a $1,000 Golden Opulence Sundae (by far the most expensive item in the place), which requires 48 hours notice to prepare and contains real gold. Reservations are accepted and tables book months in advance, so plan early or walk in and expect to wait. But that is part of the experience, too. 

Alice's Tea Cup – Upper East Side and Upper West Side
See website for locations ​
Walking into one of the three Alice's Tea Cup locations is like walking right into Lewis Carroll's storybook. It's also my personal go-to spot for a perfect tea service with my son; this isn't an experience just for girls. While my son wouldn't dare wear the fairy wings waitstaff loans out to kids, he does enjoy the magical experience of digging into the Wee Tea served on a 3-tiered tray and trying different varieties of herbal tea. Alice's decor is charming and really sets the tone for a special occasion with deliberately mismatched china and old fashioned tables and chairs. All locations can get crowded, especially for brunch, but I have had good luck walking in on weekday afternoons. You can also make a reservation.   

Sundaes with a side of nostalgia at Eddie's Sweet Shop in Forest Hills. 

Eddie's Sweet Shop – Forest Hills
105-29 Metropolitan Avenue at 72nd Road
No faux nostalgia here, Eddie's is the real deal! This soda shop has been dishing up ice cream sundaes, banana splits and malteds in Forest Hills for decades. A visit to Eddie's is a trip back in time, as many of the furnishings are original including the counter, stools, cash register and all the serving dishes. The ice cream and toppings are made in-house, so you know it's going to be good. But don't take my word for it, just look at the photo above of Raven's daughter moments before she devoured her huge sundae.   

Grown-up flavors and sophistication for NYC kids at ChikaLicious Dessert Bar.

ChikaLicious Dessert Bar – East Village
203 East 10th Street between First and Second Avenues
This small, sleek and contemporary 20-seat dessert-only restaurant was a favorite special-occasion spot during my pre-parenting days. And I am thrilled my son is now old enough to enjoy ChikaLicious, too. Desserts here are given star-status and created with the same care and precision you would expect from a savory destination. Take a seat at the bar and watch as chefs prepare and plate your prix fixe, three-course tasting menu. The options change daily, but always include an amuse-bouche, a main course dessert and petit fours. The experience is as sophisticated as it sounds, with pink peppercorn ice cream, basil sorbet and wine-based sauces on the menu. ChikaLicious doesn't take reservations and there is often a wait, but it's always a wonderful experience—especially for older kids and tweens who can appreciate the sophisticated flavors. My son was 9-years-old when he went the first time. That's him above, dining on an elegantly-plated fromage blanc cheesecake. For squirmy tots, you may want to try the carry-out ChikaLicious Dessert Club across the street. 

Spot Dessert Bar – Midtown West and East Village
13 St. Mark's Place between Second and Third Avenues
11 West 32nd in Food Gallery​ between Fifth and Sixth Avenues
While other eateries on this list offer specialized decor or over-the-top experiences, this popular dessert destination is modern and minimalistic with a big focus on flavor. The creations here are an incredible mash-up of Western desserts and exotic, Asian flavors. Kids will love the taste surprises like Thai tea infused creme brulee, taro flavored macrons and Spot's signature dish, green tea molten chocolate cake. While the atmosphere is casual with counter service, the dishes arrive beautifully presented with tons of wow factor. 

Dylan's Candy Bar – Upper East Side 
1101 Third Avenue between 60th and 61st Streets
The now-classic candy chain is on our list of Top 100 things to do in NYC for a reason. The ground floor is like walking into a real-life candy land, with bins full of every sort of imaginable confection. However, upstairs the real treat awaits—the remodeled Candy Cafe. While there is often a wait for a table (reservations are available) and the savory options are almost an afterthought, kids will love sitting in a famous cupcake table and digging into indulgent treats like frozen hot chocolate, mega ice cream sundaes sprinkled with candy toppings, candy and fruit-topped pizzas and yummy s'mores.   

A lesson in yesteryear at Brooklyn Farmacy in Carroll Gardens: these gadget addicts are perplexed by the rotary phone.

Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain – Carroll Gardens
513 Henry Street at Sackett Street
This Carroll Gardens 1920s pharmacy has been been lovingly restored to its original splendor and is a favorite destination of our blogger Teri and her tween-aged son. Dripping in nostalgia without being kitschy, Brooklyn Farmacy is a bona fide soda shop where kids can order classic egg creams, lime rickeys, ice cream sundaes and other classic soda shop goodies. I visited with my son and nephew last summer and it was a real ice cream parlor experience for my ice cream parlor-deprived Manhattan-based son. Brooklyn Farmacy is a trip back in time, complete with a soda jerk and waiter service in the communal dining room. The classic-with-a-twist menu options include modern interpretations of old-fashioned favorites like sundaes with mix-ins and egg creams in caramel, maple and butterscotch along with the traditional chocolate.  

Sugar and Plumm – Upper West Side and Greenwich Village
377 Amsterdam between 78th and 79th Streets
257 Bleecker Street at Cornelia Street
The local, homemade candy chain offers two dining experiences, one in each shop. The Upper West Side Parisian-style bistro includes a full menu of savory items, as well as desserts. Think decadent sundaes, like the delicious-sounding Monkey Business (peanut butter ice cream, sliced banana and chocolate-covered pretzels). While the Greenwich Village outpost, which includes a backroom parlor, serves seven over-the-top sundaes like the Mish Mosh (chocolate ice cream, Oreo crumbs, blondie bits, potato chips and gummy bears, topped with fudge sauce) and Jack Tripper (chocolate ice cream, fudge and salted-caramel sauce, blondie and brownie bits and peanuts). There are outrageous milk shakes, too. 

Sugar Factory – Meatpacking District
46 Gansevoort Street at Greenwich Street
Kids can party like rock stars at this luxe candy emporium. Tucked in the back of Sugar Factory is a massive, full-service restaurant that is known for its extravagant desserts. Kids can dive into candy-sprinkled waffles, pancakes or crepes for a post-dinner treat or dig into a fondue or a sundae made for two or more. Sugar Factory also offers some seriously excessive sweets like 60-ounce drinks served in goblets (with or without alcohol) and filled with gummy bears, worms or sharks, as well as super-premium indulgences like the chocolate gold fondue with gold-dusted cupcakes, candies and other delicacies to dip into truffle that is melted at your table. 

For more kid-friendly dining, check out our Restaurant Guide.

Top image: Serendipity's Frozen Hot Chocolate. Photo by m01229 via Flickr.

Max Brenner
841 Broadway
New York, NY 10003

Serendipity 3
225 E 60th St
New York, NY 10022

Alice's Tea Cup
102 W 73rd St
New York, NY 10023

Alice's Tea Cup
156 E 64th St
New York, NY 10065

Alice's Tea Cup
220 E 81st St
New York, NY 10028

Eddie's Sweet Shop
105-29 Metropolitan Ave #1 Queens, NY 11375
Queens, NY 11375

ChikaLicious Dessert Bar
203 E 10th St
New York, NY 10009

Spot Dessert Bar
13 St Marks Pl
New York, NY 10003

Spot Dessert Bar Food Gallery 32
11 W 32nd St , NY 10001

Dylan's Candy Bar
1011 3rd Ave
New York, NY 10065

Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain
513 Henry St
Brooklyn, NY 11231

Sugar and Plumm
377 Amsterdam Ave
New York, NY 10024

Sugar and Plumm
257 Bleecker St
New York, NY 10014

Sugar Factory
46 Gansevoort St
New York, NY 10014
Wednesday Greenmarket at Bartel-Pritchard Square
Bartel-Pritchard Square - 8:00 AM Pick
Free Comic Book Day 2020
- various times Pick
A Hamilton Read-Along
- various times Pick
Sing It Out!
Zoom - various times Pick
Neighborhood Guides
Activity Guides