Not So Scary & Haunted Hayrides at Benner's Farm

Fri Oct 17, 2025 - Sat Oct 25, 2025
- see all dates
Repeating every days through October 25, 2025.
Various times
Age: 3+
Price: $16/ticket (tickets will not be sold at the door)
Location:
Benner's Farm
631-689-8172
56 Gnarled Hollow Road, East Setauket, NY, 11733
Invite a friend Website

Get ready for a spine-tingling adventure at Benner’s Farm! As the moon rises, the farm transforms into a spooky (but family-friendly!) destination filled with thrills, chills, and Halloween fun for all ages.

They offer two types of ticketed experiences, so every family can choose their level of spook:

  • Not So Scary Ticket Times – Perfect for younger visitors and those who prefer a gentler ride through the haunted woods. Just the right amount of Halloween fun without the fright!
  • General Scare Tickets – For the brave and bold! These rides take you deep into the haunted woods where the scares get a little more intense and the shadows a bit darker.

Each ticket clearly states which experience it’s for, making it easy for families to pick the perfect adventure. No tickets will be sold at the door. 

Benner's Farm may add October 31 and November 1, so stay tuned!

 

** Activity dates/times are subject to change. Please click through to the activity website to verify.